Briefing on situation around former Metropolitan Philaret of Kiev’s appeal
December 1, 2017 – During a break between sessions of the Bishops’ Council of the Russian Orthodox Church, Metropolitan Hilarion of Volokolamsk, head of the Moscow Patriarchate department for external church relations (DECR), and Archbishop Clement of Irpen, head of the Ukrainian Orthodox Church’s synodal information department, answered questions from mass media reporters at the Council’s media center. The briefing was moderated by Rev. Alexander Volkov, head of the Patriarchal Press Service.
Mass media reporters were interested in particular in whether a meeting between His Holiness Patriarch Kirill and former Metropolitan Philaret was planned. ‘Such a meeting is not planned for the time being’, Metropolitan Hilarion informed them, ‘On our part, we have set up a commission for conducting negotiations with the structure headed by former Metropolitan Philaret of Kiev and All Ukraine. If these negotiations are successful we will certainly be able to think about further step as well’.
Answering the question from Interfax news agency about why the word ‘pardon’, which had been used by the agency in its report about the letter of former Metropolitan Philaret, is incorrect and cannot be regarded as belonging to the church lexicon, the DECR chairman stressed that ‘The official church lexicon should be familiarized with through official texts published by the Church. When the aim is to create a sensation or provoke a discussion, these texts are supplemented with certain overtones or some terms that are absent from these texts, thus inflicting damage and harm on the Church’s cause’.
‘I would like to express my protest to Interfax news agency against the provocative publication which appeared late night yesterday and provoked a very indignant reaction in Ukraine, because no pardon whatsoever was mentioned in either the letter from former Metropolitan Philaret of Kiev or the resolution of the Russian Orthodox Church’, the archpastor continued, ‘Pardon is a term from the juridical and judicial lexicon; for instance, criminals appeal for pardon to a President. There was nothing of the kind since what was there was a call to take measures for restoring unity and a request for forgiveness. It is this request to which the Bishops’ Council responded. I am very much regret that Interfax agency so unprofessionally and incorrectly communicated what actually did not exist in either the letter or the response to it by the Bishops’ Council. I would very much hope that in future more professionalism will be shown in communicating what happened in actual fact’.
On his part, Archbishop Clement of Irpen added, ‘The above-mentioned publication has provoked a considerable response not only in the mass media, which claim to be part of the so-called Kiev Patriarchate, but also in the non-church press, which has often proved to know nothing about fine points, nor to understand them. For this reason, almost the whole day yesterday evening till the late night negative responses came from many of those who were involved in the process we are talking about today. It is very important to remember that unfortunately the division, the schism existing in Ukraine today has a very long history: for 25 years now the church unity has been absent because of enmity, accusations and confrontation. And it is very important now to find a possibility for stepping over mutual accusations and reproaches, for removing all the hate rhetoric from our discourse in order to open a way for settling this difficult problem which has inflicted suffering literally on millions of believers living in Ukraine’.
His Eminence Clement also commented on the statements made by representatives of the structure headed by former Metropolitan Philaret that the letter allegedly does not concern a desire to restore the church unity but the readiness for dialogue about autocephaly. ‘I would refer directly to the primary source, that is, the text conveyed to the Bishops’ Council and the Patriarch of Moscow. In this text, both I and I believe all the rest see not a single word about autocephaly but the point is precisely the restoration of the Eucharistic, that is, church unity. It is only in this way that it is possible to treat the document which has been received and considered by the Bishops’ Council’, the archpastor said.
Continuing the subject, Metropolitan Hilarion noted, ‘According to my feeling, which I get from the brief communication I had with representatives of this structure, there are many different tendencies in the so-called Kiev Patriarchate itself. There are those who have taken a very explicit autocephalic stand; for them there is no other subject for discussion except for the recognition of autocephaly. There are those who are set for a more constructive dialogue. I think, if we now set up commissions for dialogue on the both sides, its beginning is possible only if we do not lay down any preconditions. We should hear each other in the course of this dialogue, try to collate our positions and understand whether we can move on or not. But now any discussion in the public space on any preconditions for dialogue can prevent it from beginning. By the way, I said that to those who brought the letter over here from former Metropolitan Philaret of Kiev’.
Journalists were also interested in the way in which the letter got to Moscow. Metropolitan Hilarion clarified that the message was brought over by former Metropolitan Philaret’s envoys. ‘Contrary to statements made in Kiev now, it was not our initiative, but that of the representatives of the letter’s author himself’, His Eminence stated, ‘They addressed us first through their representatives in America and only after that directly us’.
‘I met with them. The letter was conveyed, and since it was addressed not only to His Holiness Patriarch Kirill but also to the whole episcopate of the Russian Orthodox Church, it is only natural that it was read out at the Bishops’ Council’, the DECR chairman noted stressing that the response to this letter was given by the Resolution of the Bishops’ Council ‘On the appeal of former Metropolitan Philaret of Kiev and All Ukraine’, which was adopted last evening.
Bishops’ Council information service
- 02.12.2017 23:58Final session of the Bishops’ Council of the Russian Orthodox Church held with the participation of Primates and representatives of the Local Orthodox Churches
- 02.12.2017 16:50Bishops’ Council of the Russian Orthodox Church adopts its final documents
- 02.12.2017 14:00Resolutions of the Holy Bishops’ Council of the Russian Orthodox Church (29th November – 2nd December 2017)
- 02.12.2017 13:58Message by the Holy Episcopal Council to the Clergy, Monks and Nuns and All Faithful Children of the Russian Orthodox Church
- 01.12.2017 18:48Speech by His Holiness Patriarch Kirill at the Meeting of the President of Russia Vladimir Vladimirovich Putin with the Participants of the Episcopal Council of the Russian Orthodox Church
- 01.12.2017 18:38Speech by the President of Russia Vladimir Vladimirovich Putin before the Participants of the Episcopal Council of the Russian Orthodox Church
- 01.12.2017 16:30Briefing on situation around former Metropolitan Philaret of Kiev’s appeal
- 01.12.2017 12:38Bishops’ Council of the Russian Orthodox Church begins its third day
- 30.11.2017 23:56Metropolitan Hilarion of Volokolamsk comments on spreading reports on the appeal of the former Metropolitan of Kiev and All Ukraine
- 30.11.2017 23:50Bishops’ Council of the Russian Orthodox Church completes its second day work
- 30.11.2017 23:45Bishops’ Council of the Russian Orthodox Church adopts a Resolution ‘On the Appeal of the former Metropolitan Philaret of Kiev and All Ukraine’
- 30.11.2017 23:30Former Metropolitan Philaret of Kiev and All Ukraine: ‘I ask for your forgiveness in everything in which I sinned by word, deed and all my feelings’
- 30.11.2017 12:12Report by Metropolitan Onufry of Kiev and All Ukraine to the Russian Orthodox Church Bishops’ Council (November 29-December 2, 2017)
- 30.11.2017 12:08His Beatitude Metropolitan Onufry of Kiev and All Ukraine gives an address at the Bishops’ Council
- 30.11.2017 12:05Second day of the Bishops’ Council’s work
- 29.11.2017 22:30METROPOLITAN HILARION OF VOLOKOLAMSK SPEAKS AT THE SESSION OF THE EPISCOPAL COUNCIL OF THE RUSSIAN ORTHODOX CHURCH ON THE RESULTS OF STUDYING THE DOCUMENTS OF THE COUNCIL ON CRETE
- 29.11.2017 22:15HIS HOLINESS PATRIARCH KIRILL: “THE MEETING ON CUBA WAS AN IMPORTANT STEP ON THE WAY TO RESOLVING THE MORE RELEVANT ISSUES OF THE MODERN-DAY WORLD BY THE JOINT EFFORTS OF THE TWO LARGEST CHURCHES OF THE CHRISTIAN WORLD”
- 29.11.2017 21:28His Holiness notes positive dynamics in Church-state cooperation in Uzbekistan
- 29.11.2017 21:25His Holiness Patriarch Kirill expresses hope that the dialogue between the Church and Turkmenistan’s leadership will help resolve current difficulties
- 29.11.2017 21:22His Holiness specifies pressing problems of the Orthodox Church in Tajikistan
- 29.11.2017 21:20Primate of the Russian Church expresses satisfaction with the level of Church-state cooperation in Kyrgyzstan
- 29.11.2017 21:18His Holiness Patriarch Kirill: Republic of Kazakhstan has been giving an example of constructive Church-state relations for many years
- 29.11.2017 21:17His Holiness Patriarch Kirill: Dialogue of Azerbaijani authorities with Diocese of Baku offers ample opportunities for solving problems of the Orthodox
- 29.11.2017 21:16His Holiness Patriarch Kirill notes a high level dialogue between the Church and the state in Belarus
- 29.11.2017 21:14Positive tendencies in church-state relations in Moldova are noted in the report of His Holiness the Patriarch at the Bishops’ Council
- 29.11.2017 21:10His Holiness Patriarch Kirill: Peacemaking heroic deeds of the Ukrainian Orthodox Church show its true patriotism
- 29.11.2017 19:35HIS HOLINESS PATRIARCH KIRILL: “SIN OUGHT TO BE EXPOSED, BUT WE SHOULD NEVER HUMILIATE ANYONE”
- 29.11.2017 18:51HIS HOLINESS PATRIARCH KIRILL: “COMMUNICATING WITH THE MEDIA IS A CHANCE TO SPEAK ABOUT THE GOSPEL IN AN ACCESIBLE LANGUAGE ON ISSUES WHICH AFFECT TODAY’S PEOPLE”
- 29.11.2017 17:38His Holiness Patriarch Kirill told members of the Bishops’ Council about the preparation of the Catechesis of the Russian Orthodox Church
- 29.11.2017 17:34Primate of Russian Church calls to adopt more systematic approach in opposing sectarianism and neo-paganism
- 29.11.2017 17:27His Holiness Patriarch Kirill: What is sometimes forgotten in pursuit of different technologies is that mission is not a collection of methods, but practical work
- 29.11.2017 17:24His Holiness Patriarch Kirill: The main task of the Church is not to fill children’s mind with vast knowledge, but to help them enter into its life
- 29.11.2017 17:18Primate of Russian Orthodox Church: Theology should be regarded not only as a set of subjects taught at seminaries, but also as a serious science
- 29.11.2017 17:08Reorganization of the system of theological education remains priority for supreme church authorities
- 29.11.2017 17:06His Holiness Patriarch Kirill: While inviting young people to dialogue and using their language, the Church must not lose its integrity
- 29.11.2017 16:59Patriarch Kirill: For the youth it is important that Christianity is a religion of freedom, not a religion of bans
- 29.11.2017 14:33Patriarch Kirill: Signing the Act of Canonical Communion has given us joy over the unity of the faithful of the one Russian Orthodox Church
- 29.11.2017 14:32Patriarch Kirill announces statistical data on the life of the Russian Orthodox Church
- 29.11.2017 14:28Bishops’ Council given information on Patriarch ministry in inter-council period
- 29.11.2017 14:19Patriarch Kirill: Continued attempts are made to impose on the Church a life according to the rules of this world
- 29.11.2017 14:10THE FIRST HIERARCH OF THE RUSSIAN ORTHODOX CHURCH : THE MINISTRY OF THE BISHOP IS INEXTRIABLY LINKED TO THE ORTHODOX UNDERSTANDING OF CONCILIARITY
- 29.11.2017 14:07HIS HOLINESS PATRIARCH KIRILL: THE LOCAL COUNCIL OF 1917-1918 WAS TRULY AN EXTRAORDINARY PEHNOMENON IN THE HISTORY OF THE CHURCH
- 29.11.2017 14:04HIS HOLINESS PATRIARCH KIRILL: THE MAIN HERITAGE OF THE NEW MARTYRS IS THEIR LOVE OF CHRIST AND NEIGHBOUR, FOR WHOM THEY LAID DOWN THEIR LIVES
- 29.11.2017 14:01Opening of the Bishops’ Council of the Russian Orthodox Church
- 29.11.2017 13:56President of Kazakhstan Nursultan Nazarbayev sends greetings to participants in Bishops’ Council of the Russian Orthodox Church
- 29.11.2017 13:55President of Moldova Igor Dodon sends greetings to participants in Bishops’ Council of the Russian Orthodox Church
- 29.11.2017 13:53President of Belarus Alexander Lukashenko sends greetings to participants in the Bishops’ Council of the Russian Orthodox Church
- 29.11.2017 13:50President Putin’s message of greetings to the Bishops’ Council of the Russian Orthodox Church